II

MARY AND CONSECRATED LIFE :
A PROFOUND HARMONY

17. After having examined the recent crisis in Marian devotion and the way it has been virtually overcome in the Church and religious institutes, we think it useful to continue our reflection by looking at Mary from our particular existential viewpoint as religious and in terms of the service which we can render to the local Churches. The Blessed Virgin Mary is a “good” which belongs to the entire Church and to all generations. She performs her maternal ministry on behalf of all those who believe in Christ and on behalf of all men and women. Because of the purity of her acceptance of the Father's will and the Son's message, she offers herself to everyone - men and women, bishops, priests and deacons, religious and laity - as a perfect image of the faithful disciple of Christ. The patristic Church expressed its conviction that the life of the Blessed Virgin was a model for all the disciples of the Lord.25 According to the tradition and unbroken experience of the Church, therefore, it is not possible for religious to arrogate the “Marian model” to themselves.

A historical responsibility


18. According to the exegetes, the New Testament (particularly the gospels of Luke and John) shows definite traces of veneration of the Mother of Jesus by the first Christian communities. Patristic scholars point out that the writings of the second and third centuries contain not a few references to the Church's increasing attention to Mary expressed in respectful honour of her dignity as the Mother of Christ and the new Eve. Archaeologists have also unearthed evidence of Marian devotion in various excavations, dating back to the second and third centuries, mainly in Palestine and Rome. We therefore have a variety of evidence that assures us that in the pre-Nicene period (before organised forms of “religious life” emerged) there existed in the Church a fairly well defined veneration of the Mother of the Redeemer. Yet there can be no doubt that in both the East and the West, later developments of Marian doctrine and devotion were largely due to the insight, commitment and love of men and women consecrated to God in religious life. In the patristic age this occured among the groups of ascetics, during the Middle Ages in the monastic foundations and communities of the new orders dedicated to the evangelical-apostolic life, all of which had a marked veneration for the glorious Virgin. In the modern and contemporary periods, this occurs in numerous congregations and institutes with a more clearly defined apostolic commitment in which the Marian charism is often forcefully asserted. A glance at the saints, men and women, who were outstanding for a particular “Marian feature” in the eyes of the faithful or according to the judgment of history reveals that most of them were religious.

19. It was in the monasteries that the superb icons were painted, resplendent with that mysterious “presence” of the Theotokos and bearing a message of beauty and doctrine. Here, too, the great Marian hymns and homilies were written and a number of the important feasts of the Blessed Virgin were established as well as the practice of dedicating Saturday to her. The practice of greeting the Blessed Virgin at the end of the canonical hours and in particular the solemn prayer to the Regina misericordiae which concludes the daily offices, the Angelus at daybreak, noon and evening, and the diffusion of the little offices of St. Mary are linked with these monasteries. Most of the leading scholars of the figure of the Blessed Virgin and many of the most fervent defenders of her privileges were religious. Virtually all the treatises on Marian spirituality and the most commonly practiced Marian exercises came from the “religious” context. Many shrines dedicated to the Blessed Virgin were and are entrusted to religious who have also been the promoters of countless Marian associations.
      We religious have to view all this not as a reason for foolish and sterile praise of ourselves, but as a historical fact to be reflected upon, an invitation not to squander this “family legacy” and as an incentive to further the work that our predecessors began many centuries ago.

20. Since the pontificate of Pius IX (1846-1878), the Supreme Pontiffs have frequently spoken out in the exercise of their universal magisterium to safeguard and foster Marian devotion among the faithful. Many bishops of local Churches have followed the example of the bishops of Rome. This is primarily their responsibility. But without fear of falling into rhetoric, we can affirm that religious, not because of doctrine or pastoral responsibility but because of a centuries' old tradition, have the “historic responsibility” to be faithful trustees of devotion to the Mother of the Lord and to promote its correct development. This responsibility is one that we do not intend to shirk and is a burden which, like the “yoke” of the law of Jesus (see Mt 11:30), we find easy and light.



A profound harmony

21. We have already mentioned that Mary's life can be taken on by all the disciples of the Lord according to the norms of the evangelical life. Nevertheless, because of her unique and unrepeatable vocation lived in very particular circumstances, the role of model which is Mary's as true mother and perfect virgin is seen in different ways according to the various states of life; she is seen in one way for example in the life of those who live in matrimony and in another way in the life of those who have embraced celibacy for the Kingdom. John Paul II has stated that “marriage and virginity or celibacy are two ways of expressing and living the one mystery of the covenant of God with his people.”26 Virginity and matrimony are two distinct expressions of the same necessary following of Christ.

The family of Nazareth as model

22. Those who are united in holy matrimony feel that Mary and Joseph, because of their communion of faith, affection and life, are a shining point of reference for them. The birth of Jesus, son of God and son of man, took place within a family established according to the law of the Lord and made up of a just man (see Mt 1:19) of the house of David (see Mt 1:20; Lk 1: 27) and a divinely favoured woman (see Lk 1:28). After Joseph, following the command of the angel, took Mary into his home as his wife (see Mt 1:20, 24), their life seems marked by profound wedded communion: together, they faced the hardships brought on by the census decreed by Augustus Caesar (see Lk 2:1-5); together, they lived the salvific event of the birth of Jesus in joy and in poverty (see Lk 2:7); together, they are seen in the fulfillment of the sign given to the shepherds by the angel (see Lk 2:16); together they carried out the rites prescribed by the law of the Lord: the circumcision of the child and the giving of a name (see Lk 2:21), the presentation of the newborn in the Temple (see Lk 2:27) and “their purification” (Lk 2:22); after the words of Simeon (see Lk 2:29-32), together “the child's father and mother marvelled at what was being said about him” (Lk 2:33) and together they were blessed by the old holy man (see Lk 2:34); together, they faced the difficult trials of the persecution by Herod and the flight into Egypt (see Mt 2:13-15); after returning to Nazareth, together they “used to go every year to Jerusalem for the feast of the Passover” (Lk 2:41); with the same feelings of sorrow they lived through the prophetic episode of the loss of Jesus (Lk 2:48)- together they sought him, found him and were astonished; Jesus returned to Nazareth with them and was obedient to them as their son (see Lk 2:51); together, they lived a humble, hidden and active life in such a way that Jesus was considered to be “the son of the carpenter” (Mt 13:55) or simply “the carpenter” (Mk 6:3).
      Because of all this, the home in Nazareth has remained in the memory of the Church as the example of where we learn “what the family is and what communion in love is its austere and simple beauty, its sacred and enduring character.”27 In particular Mary, because of her physical motherhood and educational role in the life of the child Jesus, is celebrated as the model for Christian mothers. At this point we permit ourselves to express a two-fold hope:

      
That those who live in matrimony or are preparing to celebrate it will attain their desire for communion and love also in light of the married life of Joseph and Mary. That life seems characterised by two elements: it was lived “according to the law of the Lord” and it expressed a mutual willingness to face together, as we have seen, the great and small events that confronted them. Further, thinking of the virginal marriage of Mary and Joseph, Christian spouses will be able to understand the ultimate meaning of sexuality (which was also lived by Mary and Joseph, though in a unique way)28 and experience their mutual giving of self as a moment of profound communion and participation in the mystery of life within the context of the plan that comes from the Lord.

      
That after the many voices (usually those of celibate theologians) which have described the various aspects of the motherhood of Mary throughout the centuries, it be described also by women who have lived the same human experience.

Supreme model of consecrated virginity

23. And yet this woman Mary, so truly mother, has since the second century been considered the “virgin” par excellence, the “Virgin of the Lord.”29 Very early, Christian thought understood the dogmatic implications of her virginity and beginning in the third century Mary was primarily presented as the model or most excellent image of consecrated virginity. Why was this? Why is there this singular connection between “Marian devotion” and “religious life” which we spoke of earlier ? Vatican II provides an answer rich in implications: the evangelical counsels that religious freely embrace “have the power to conform the Christian man or woman more fully to that kind of poor and virginal life which Christ the Lord chose for himself and which his Virgin Mother embraced also.” 30 There is, therefore, a profound consistency between the evangelical essence of the “religious life” and certain fundamental aspects of the “life of the Virgin” as described in the gospel. This consistency explains the age-old, cordial relationship between “Marian piety” and the consecrated life. By living in essence the same “ kind of life” as Mary, religious have a more immediate grasp of certain “values” of the figure of the Virgin and are better equipped to gain an existential appreciation of the nuances which wholly escape others.

24. In the light of historical experience and this recognised “profound harmony” between Mary's “kind of life” and the consecrated life, we can say without making an axiom of it, that wherever the gospel-inspired religious life is lived with commitment, genuine devotion to the Mother of Jesus flourishes. Conversely, wherever there is sound devotion to the Blessed Virgin, the most favourable conditions for the growth of consecrated life are found. This perhaps explains what is happening in some groups of men and women in the Reformed Churches. They have rigorously restored the forms and structures of life that belong to the monastic-religious tradition, including celibacy for the Kingdom, and at the same time they have rediscovered the significance and value of the figure of Mary in relation to the “Christian life.”

The model of our vocation and consecration

25. Because of her civil status Mary is a “lay woman” even if she belongs to a consecrated people (see Dt 14:2). Yet reflecting on the gospels, the tradition of the Church presents Mary as the epitome of the “consecrated woman,” as the most pure and the greatest example, after Christ, of personal consecration to God and the cause of salvation. Being consecrated by the sanctifying action of the Spirit from her Immaculate Conception and, subsequently, by the ineffable presence of the Word in her virginal womb, Mary freely and totally consecrated herself to God in generously responding to his call.31 In the light of the New Testament we can say that by virtue of her singular consecration, everything in Mary's life is in reference to God, everything expresses a relationship with the Father, the Son and the Spirit, and everything is oriented to the salvation of humanity.

26. The exegetes tell us that the text of the Annunciation in St. Luke's Gospel (1:26-38) is not to be read solely as a typical “announcement of birth” but also as a typical “account of vocation,” the vocation to be the mother of the Messiah but a vocation understood always as a “personal call” that demanded a “personal response.” The same exegetes point out that no account of vocation contains such a detailed dialogue with so much respect for a person's freedom as does the encounter between Gabriel and Mary. Furthermore, no other account ends with such an expressive formula of wholehearted acceptance of the Lord's will as the one used by the Blessed Virgin in accepting the divine plan: “I am the handmaid of the Lord, let it be done to me according to your word” (Lk 1:38).

27. Following the teaching of the Fathers, religious have meditated at great length on these words spoken by the Blessed Virgin. Through the ages, they have thoroughly examined the significance of Mary's fiat and have shown that it is an echo of the word spoken at the beginning of time (Gen 1:3,26); that the fiat was spoken to enable the Spirit to form Christ, the true Light and the true New Man, in her virginal womb; that it was the obedient response counteracting Eve's doom-laden denial; that it echoed the formula of the “Sinai covenant” (see Ex 19:8) and to a certain extent was its first manifestation in the economy of the new Covenant. Religious have seen that the fiat is the wonderful encounter between the word spoken by the Son as he enters the world (see Heb 10:5-7; Ps 39:8-9) and the word spoken by the Virgin as she welcomed him into her womb (see Lk 1:38). It was a “consent to marriage” in that after the fiat the Word indissolubly united his divine nature to our human nature in Mary's womb. It was the paradigm of all motherhood of grace in the Church which can only take place in faith and in the Spirit. It was the word of unconditional acceptance which, by accepting a message of liberation (see Lk 1:31-33), became a pledge to serve. It was a word of mercy which the Virgin - privileged daughter of Adam, yet united to all men and women- spoke on behalf of all.32 Obviously, not all these “readings” of Mary's fiat can be drawn from the literal sense of the biblical text, but they do bear witness to the attention which the Church and religious of all ages have paid to that decisive word.

28. We are certain that you, bishops, priests and deacons, and you, brothers and sisters of the laity, can understand us. We religious, following a longstanding and solid tradition and without any claim that we monopolise the model, interpret the vocation to the “consecrated life” (personal call from God and the following of Christ in a chaste, humble and obedient life at the service of the Church...) in the light of Mary's vocation. We therefore hold that God extends certain aspects of Mary's vocation in the vocation of virgins and religious. What in Mary's case was the vocation to become the mother of the Messiah, to beget Christ in heart and in flesh, bocomes the religious' call to a virginal fecundity in the Spirit which generates Christ in accepting the Word and fulfilling the will of the Father (see Mt 12:49-50).
      We also interpret our “ religious consecration ” in the light of Mary's consecration: the radical way in which she “devoted herself totally as the handmaid of the Lord to the person and work of her Son, under and with him, serving the mystery of redemption, by the grace of Almighty God.” 33 She stands before us as the norm for living out the commitment of love we have made to Christ and our fellow men and women and for remaining true to the pledge we have given.

An extension and a sign of a presence

29. The pilgrim Church on earth lives with the consoling assurance of its Lord: “I am with you always, to the end of time” (Mt 28:20b). The risen Christ who sits in glory at the right hand of the Father is constantly present in the Church, his spouse. Indeed, we know that being united to the mystery of the death and resurrection of Christ (see Rom 6:3-11 ) all baptised Christians have been transformed in Christ; Christ lives in them (see Gal 2:20) and they become Christ's dwelling (see Jn 14:23).
       Similarly, the Blessed Virgin assumed into heaven, who reigns in glory beside her son, the “King of kings and Lord of lords”(Rev 19:16), is effectively present in the life of the Church. The Second Vatican Council, making its own the perennial tradition of the Church, spoke with force and clarity: “Taken up to heaven, [Mary] did not lay aside this saving office, but by her manifold intercession continues to bring us the gifts of eternal salvation. By her maternal charity, she cares for the brothers and sisters of her son who still journey on earth surrounded by dangers and difficulties, until they are led to their blessed home.”34 Contemporary theology is reconsidering the doctrine of Mary's mediation, without rejecting its traditional content, in terms of the exercise of her spiritual motherhood and referring to the Fathers of the Church it speaks clearly of the “presence” of Mary in the life of the Church.35 In the same way, Paul VI and John Paul II have frequently used the expression “active presence” in their teaching to show the actual and hidden way in which the Virgin who already possesses “the glory of the celestial bodies” (1 Cor 15:40) and is therefore unconstrained by time and space shares in the activities and life of the Church in its earthly and temporal stage.36

30. The many different ways Christ is present in the Church are manifested through a variety of signs. These are all well known and the Fathers of the Church, theologians, and the bishops of Rome have written many eloquent pages on them.37
      But are there any signs of the presence of the Blessed Virgin in the Church? We believe there are.38 And we ask ourselves if among these signs we should not include religious who by free choice are specially bound to the Mother of Christ, and who draw their inspiration from her as the model for their own lives. We want to respond with great caution, asking the help of the reflection of our brothers and sisters.

31. Christ alone is the source and supreme model of religious life. He alone presents the divine and human realities of a life whose essence is infinite love for the Father and total self-giving to his brothers and sisters with absolute unity and absolute depth. But we know that despite their personal fragility, religious, because of the state they have embraced, place themselves in relationship to Christ as an extension and sign. As Vatican II exhorts: “ Let religious see well to it that the Church truly show forth Christ through them with ever-increasing clarity to believers and unbelievers alike - Christ in contemplation on the mountain or proclaiming the Kingdom of God to the multitudes, or healing the sick and maimed, and converting sinners to a good life, or blessing children, and doing good to all, always in obedience to the will of the Father who sent him.”39

32. Our Lady does not generate grace. She has no light of her own. She reflects the light of Christ as the moon reflects the light of the sun, as a metaphor well known to the Fathers of the Church has it. She is merely the face which most resembles the face of Christ, the splendour of the glory of the Father (see Heb 1:3). Not knowing sin, the Virgin already represents the new heart, the docile heart, which is required for the new Covenant which God was to make with his new people (see Jer 31 :31-34 ). She already possesses the “pure heart” which her son proclaimed blessed and capable of “ secing God ” (see Mt 5:8).
      By virtue of the quality of her response to the gift of grace and the mission she received from God, the Blessed Virgin appears to the Church as the model of mysterious holiness. 40 The Church loves to contemplate Mary to draw from her words and attitudes inspiration for the responses it must make to its Lord in the various events of history so that it can experience a foretaste of its destiny of glory. Religious, too, love to contemplate Mary; it is their habit to look to the Blessed Virgin to learn from her how to live fruitfully their consecrated virginity, their voluntary poverty and their generous obedience.

33. But we have to clarify this still further. The exemplary character of the Blessed Virgin is in itself an effect of her “active presence” in the ecclesial community; it is the strength that is released by her person, already glorified and consumed in love, which leads the faithful to conform themselves to her in order to conform themselves more fully to Christ. In this way, through the action of the Spirit and according to structures of grace that cannot be codified the faithful conforming themselves to the model reproduce it, in reproducing it they extend it, in extending it they make it present among men and women.

A great symbol of Christianity

34. The Blessed Virgin is certainly one of the greatest symbols of Christianity; by the term “ symbol” we mean a historical reality which embodies a set of ideal attitudes and hence is not limited by the confines of fleeting time and which extends its saving function to all generations in the economy of salvation and is susceptible to becoming ever better known, but whose mystery will be wholly revealed only at the end of time.
      The founders and foundresses of many religious families took their inspiration from the Blessed Virgin, this inexhaustible reality-symbol. Some concentrated their attention on the great event of the Incarnation of the Word and hence on Mary's fiat, full of obedience and faith, whereby she became through the action of the Spirit, the Mother of God made man and the sacred dwelling of the Word. Drawing out the full significance and value of the expression “I am the handmaid of the Lord” (Lk 1:38), they felt the urgent need to put it into practice by making their own lives a service of love to God, the Church and all men and women.
      Others were attracted by the salvific content of the episode of the Visitation in which Mary, the new ark of the New Covenant, brought the Saviour to John and proclaimed the great things that God had done for her and for Israel. Accordingly, these founders and foundresses desired to make themselves Christ-bearers to all peoples and through their lives extend the song of thanksgiving and liberation.      
      There were others still who saw the wealth of meaning in the episode of the Presentation of Jesus in the Temple and desired to take it as the paradigm for their lives. They placed before the eyes of their followers as a constant example Mary and Joseph's loving observance of the law: the humility of the pure Virgin, the ransom paid with two turtledoves for the Firstborn Son who was to redeem all men and women with the price of his blood (see 1 Pt 1 :19; Rev 5 :9); the meeting of the Messiah with his people in the Temple (not however with the guardians of the Temple, but with the poor, the anawim (Simeon and Anna); above all, the prophetic words which greeted Jesus, “a light to the Gentiles and the glory of Israel” (see Lk 2:32), and which announced to his mother her participation in the passion of her son- the sword of sorrow (see Lk 2:35).
      Others proposed that their sons and daughters should draw their inspiration from the operative silence of the home in Nazareth in which Mary, at Joseph's side, was both the mother and the disciple of Jesus, faithfully keeping and pondering in her heart the words and events relating to their son (see Lk 2:19, 51) and not fully understanding the significance of some of his actions (see Lk 2:50), but giving herself wholly to pure faith.
      Others proposed to concentrate on living their lives in terms of the event of the Hour of the Paschal Mystery - the event of pain and glory, of death and life - in which important prophecies seem to find fulfillment in Mary: the prophecy of the Woman (see Gen 3:15) who, as she stood by the tree of life, was to be called to work with the new Man for the salvation of the human race, and the prophecies relating to the Daughter of Zion, mother of all peoples (see Zep 3:14; Zech 2:14; 9:9; Ps 86 [87]:5-7). Mary personifies the Daughter of Zion, standing by the side of Christ who draws all peoples to himself as he is uplifted on the Cross (seeJn 12:32) and gathers together in the Church (seeJn 10:16) “all the children of God who are scattered abroad ” (Jn 11:52 ). In that Hour, the necessary condition for becoming a true disciple of Christ is fulfilled also for Mary: to follow him even to the Cross (see Lk 9:23). By contemplating the mystery of Calvary, these founders and foundresses discovered the means of exhorting their sons and daughters to be present as Mary was at the crosses of their brothers and sisters in whom the passion of Christ is extended.
      Others strongly desired their communities to be so many Cenacles where religious, gathered together with “Mary, the Mother of Jesus” (Acts 1:14) and in communion with the successors of the apostles and all the Lord's brothers and sisters, would be united in constant prayer to implore the unceasing gift of the Spirit for the Church.
      Lastly, there were others who found inspiration for their lives in certain events of grace which God worked in Mary and which form part of our profession of faith: the Immaculate Conception, in which the Church acknowledges her own secret beginning and sees her image, as in a spotless mirror, as the Spouse without wrinkle or blemish (Eph 5 27);41 her Assumption into heaven, in which the Church contemplates the fulfillment of the glorious destiny that awaits her; or the fruitful virginity which the Church accepts as a means of keeping the faith whole, and preserving her love for Christ exclusive and watchful.

35. These are but a few examples, yet they are far from secondary. They refer to existential experiences that have gradually enriched the life of the Church and that concern considerable numbers of groups within the Church. They are experiences that have been raised up by a founding charism, useful in “building up the community” (1 Cor 14:12) and recognised as such by the Apostolic See; experiences that have produced, and continue to produce, fruits of holiness.


* * *

      We are now in a better position to answer the question raised earlier: religious who live an evangelical life inspired expressly by Mary, by virtue of their stabile commitment rooted in a charism raised up by the Spirit, extend the “ active presence” of the Virgin in the Church and they manifest that same presence. They are a sign of that presence.
      The Blessed Virgin, assumed into heaven, is still at the service of the work of salvation and keeps watch over the Church, visiting it, comforting it,42 and performing her maternal duty through the words, deeds and hearts of religious who have consecrated themselves to her.

Mary, the witness of Christ

36. We should not be afraid that the attention paid by religious to one or other episode relating to the Blessed Virgin and taken as the inspiration for their consecrated life might distract them from their fundamental commitment of following Christ and serving the Church. It can be noted that all these episodes relate first and foremost to Christ. And they are episodes that have profound implications for the Church and, therefore, necessarily relate to the Church. We can truly say that there is no episode relating to Mary in the gospels which cannot be read in terms of the mystery of Christ and of the Church.

37. Like John the Baptist (see Jn 1:29-31), Andrew (see Jn 1:41-42), Philip (see Jn 1:45) and Peter (see Jn 6:68-69), Mary is a witness of Christ, and like them the Blessed Virgin refers all to him, the new lawgiver, and to his precepts: “Do whatever he tells you” Jn 2:5). By virtue of this “commandment” of the Blessed Virgin, in which some exegetes notice echoes of the formulae of the covenant,43 we find that Christ is the only absolute, the only way that leads to the Father (see Jn 14 :6). This is the function of Marian devotion. It is clearly expressed in the iconographic concept of the odighitria of the Blessed Virgin: she points towards Jesus who is the Way.
       But even Jesus, in a certain way, directs us towards his mother, for when we contemplate Christ in his real-life human and saving existence, from the cradle to the cross, we see Mary at his side. When he was a child, the Magi from the East were presented with the sight of “the child with Mary his mother” (Mt 2:11); when he died on the cross, Jesus entrusted his mother to John, saying, “Behold your mother” Jn 19:27). In the monastic-religious tradition, these words and actions of our Lord have been interpreted as an indication of a path leading to him.